Take the scenic route. Keep the connection.

The best part of a trip might be when your phone loses service.
With the ZOLEO Satellite Communicator and its companion app, you can send messages beyond cell coverage, share your location, and keep the people who matter part of the journey. An “I’m OK” check-in message from camp. An update when plans change. A little reassurance for everyone back home.
Make staying connected part of your packing list. Save 20% on a regularly priced ZOLEO Satellite Communicator with code CONNECT20.
Not valid on sale-priced devices or with other discounts. Valid outside promotional sale periods.

Morning, folks.
Rifle seasons are winding down, the rut is on, and the news this week gave me plenty to chew on. One of the guys who writes our hunting rules took a plea deal. A new study says we might be managing mule deer backwards. And Colorado wants to borrow Wyoming’s wolverines, even though Wyoming only has about 15 of them.
Grab a coffee and let’s get into it.
IN THIS ISSUE
The Commissioner’s Plea Deal: seven charges down to two misdemeanors
Too Many Bucks? A BYU study flips mule deer management on its head
Wolverines Headed to Colorado, maybe out of Wyoming’s tiny population
Grand Teton’s Elk Hunt Is Down to 40 Tags
Utah’s Coyote Bounty Ran Out of Money
Two Bucks Crash a Boardwalk at Muir Woods
TOP STORY
RULES FOR THEE: IDAHO’S FISH AND GAME COMMISSIONER CUTS A DEAL
He started with seven charges. He’ll plead to two misdemeanors and pay $1,000.
This one hits close to home.
Brody Harshbarger is the Upper Snake Region commissioner on the Idaho Fish and Game Commission, appointed by Gov. Brad Little. He has agreed to plead guilty to two misdemeanors: hunting without a valid tag, and shooting from or across a public highway. In exchange, prosecutors are dismissing the other five charges, including unlawfully taking big game and trespassing.
According to charging documents, last December in Fremont County, Harshbarger drove for another man who shot a bull elk on private property, then a second bull on nearby public land. Law enforcement says neither man had a valid elk tag. The whole case started with a call to the Citizens Against Poaching hotline.
The deal is a $500 fine on each charge and a one-year revocation of his hunting license. Sentencing is set for December 9. He stepped back from his commission duties in March, and his term runs until June 2027.
My take: Commissioners set our seasons, approve our regulations and oversee the department’s budget. When a regular guy in Idaho gets caught shooting a bull from the road without a tag, he isn’t usually walking away with a grand in fines and a year off. I’m not saying the man should hang. But the people who write the rules should be held to a higher standard than the rest of us, not a lower one.
And to whoever made that CAP call: thank you. That’s how it’s supposed to work.
Read more from the Idaho Capital Sun:
https://idahocapitalsun.com/2026/11/16/idaho-fish-and-game-commissioner-pleads-guilty-to-misdemeanor-hunting-charges/
And from Boise State Public Radio:
https://www.boisestatepublicradio.org/law-justice/2026-11-16/idaho-fish-game-brody-harshbarger-guilty-plea-poaching
To report poaching in Idaho, call Citizens Against Poaching at 1-800-632-5999.
THE DEER CAMP ARGUMENT STARTER
TOO MANY BUCKS? NEW STUDY SAYS WE MIGHT BE MANAGING MULE DEER BACKWARDS
More bucks per doe was supposed to grow the herd. BYU’s research says it may be doing the opposite.
For thirty years, hunters and agencies across the West have pushed for higher buck-to-doe ratios. The idea was simple: fewer buck tags means more mature bucks, better hunting and better breeding.
Researchers at BYU just published a study that pokes a big hole in that idea. It’s called “Dams in Distress,” and it was led by Ranjana Pal with professors Randy Larsen and Brock McMillan.
Working from years of Utah mule deer data, they found that as the ratio of bucks to does went up, does carried less body fat. That carried down to the fawns: lower birth weights, slower growth and lower survival.
In plain English, every extra buck is another mouth eating the same winter feed the pregnant does need.
To be fair, the study shows a link, and the researchers say they don’t know yet exactly why it happens. But it lines up with what a lot of old-timers have been saying for years.
My take: This is what happens when we manage for the Instagram photo instead of the herd. Everybody wants to see a 200-inch buck in their unit. Nobody wants to admit that might be part of why there are fewer deer, period. If this holds up, some units could see more buck tags, and a lot of guys are going to be mad about it.
Jim Zumbo made a similar case from the hunter’s side in “Trophy Deer Hunting Is a Trap.” It’s worth your five minutes.
Read the BYU story:
https://news.byu.edu/intellect/new-byu-study-why-the-current-strategy-to-manage-mule-deer-populations-may-not-be-working
KSL’s coverage:
https://www.ksl.com/article/51645220/byu-led-study-points-to-potential-reason-for-mule-deer-population-decline-in-the-west
Zumbo in Outdoor Life:
https://www.outdoorlife.com/opinion/trophy-deer-hunting-trap/
QUICK HITS FROM AROUND THE WEST
WOLVES WEREN’T ENOUGH: COLORADO WANTS WOLVERINES NEXT
They want to start in 2027, and Wyoming is on the list of places to get them.
Colorado Parks and Wildlife plans to release up to 15 wolverines per winter, about 45 total, with a long-term goal of 50 to 100 animals. The catch is that Wyoming ranks high as a possible source, and it may only have around 15 wolverines in the whole state.
Wolverines were wiped out of Colorado around 1919. The only one confirmed there since was a collared male called M56, who walked down from the Tetons in 2009 and was later shot in North Dakota.
Ranchers and hunters are already nervous about new limits on trapping and grazing. After how the wolf reintroduction went, can you blame them?
Cowboy State Daily has the story:
https://cowboystatedaily.com/2026/11/16/colorado-wants-to-reintroduce-wolverines-eyes-some-of-wyomings-endangered-15/
GRAND TETON’S ELK HUNT IS DOWN TO 40 TAGS
The park’s annual elk hunt has been cut down to almost nothing.
Grand Teton National Park’s elk reduction program opened Saturday and runs through December 6. It’s cows and calves only, in Hunt Area 75 only, and just 40 permits are authorized. Not long ago this hunt handed out hundreds of tags every year. Managers cut it by more than 90 percent to ease pressure on the Jackson Herd’s migrating elk, which have been declining.
The Park Service announcement:
https://www.nps.gov/grte/learn/news/2026-elk-reduction-program.htm
UTAH’S COYOTE BOUNTY RAN OUT OF MONEY
It turns out paying hunters $100 a dog works. Maybe too well.
Starting in April 2025, Utah doubled its coyote bounty to $100 for coyotes killed in mule deer habitat. Coyotes killed outside that habitat still pay $50. In fiscal year 2025, 462 people turned in coyotes and the state paid out $227,250. This year hunters burned through the whole budget, and check-ins stopped until the legislature added $200,000. Going forward, the program gets $450,000 a year.
Whether all those dead coyotes actually mean more fawns is still up for debate. But the guys running predator calls this winter aren’t complaining.
Utah DWR’s program page:
https://wildlife.utah.gov/coyote-faq.html
WORTH WATCHING
TWO BUCKS, ONE BOARDWALK, ZERO MANNERS
A couple of rutting black-tailed bucks at Muir Woods in California locked horns on a hillside. They rolled down onto the tourist boardwalk and kept fighting a few feet from a group of hikers. The rut doesn’t care about your redwood photo op.
Watch it here:
https://unofficialnetworks.com/2026/11/05/rutting-deer-brawl-california-national-monument/
YOUR TURN
This week’s question: If it meant more deer overall, would you trade higher buck-to-doe ratios for more buck tags in your unit?
Hit reply and tell me yes, no, or “it depends.” I read every one, and I’ll share the best answers, first names only, in the next issue.
WESTERN TRIVIA
Mule deer got their name from what feature? The answer comes in the next issue. No Googling.
KNOW A GUY WHO’D LIKE THIS?
Forward this email to a hunting buddy. Every new reader helps keep this newsletter independent, with no sponsored garbage and no influencer nonsense.
COMING UP NEXT ISSUE
What happens at the Harshbarger sentencing on December 9, your answers on the buck tag question, and the trivia answer.
PARTING SHOT
The commissioner took his deal. The deer in Utah are telling us something we don’t want to hear. And in a couple of years, there may be a wolverine walking around somewhere in the Colorado high country.
